Anchor text and Penguin updates
Rolled out a month ago, Penguin 2.0 is now widely discussed in the SEO community. At this point there’s not enough data to state that any particular SEO technique is on radar more than the rest. Yet, the current update’s predecessor, Penguin 1.0, has become notorious for its focus on anchor text diversity.
Last year Google devalued backlinks of the websites which excessively used promotional keywords as anchors and placed links on spammy websites. This is how the diversification, mixing of anchor text and backlinks quality became vital.
We believe they are still vital, so we carried out a research to see which be.
Other industry research on anchor text diversity
Several researches were carried out to check whether sites that experienced rankings drop after the Penguin update also had over-optimized anchor texts vs. more natural mix of anchors. According to some of them, the percentage of “money keywords” in anchors should not exceed 60%, 35%, 25%, 10%, etc. It doesn’t mean you should not use a keyword more than once, it just means that you should not just rotate 1-5 “money keywords” in 100% of links you acquire.
Our research on anchor text diversity
To find out what kind of anchor texts work in a long-term perspective and in what proportion, we selected rather competitive keywords like, for example, “quick weight loss”, “real estate for sale”, “cheap hotels”, “web design company”, checked which websites rank #1-2 for these keywords after the Penguin 1.0 update and classified their anchor texts by the following types:
- Brand name/Brand-keyword hybrid
- Exact match
- Partial and broad match
- Anchors in foreign languages
- Empty alt texts in linking images
- Other (completely different from the targeted keyword)
The positions were checked in three stages:
1. May 2012 (when webmasters experienced Penguin 1.0 consequences)
2. January 2013 (when Penguin 1.0 settled down and those who “deserved” punishment, got it).
3. June 2013 (we ran an extra check before publishing this article to ensure the data is relevant; very little deviation was found compared to January 2013).
“When the internet boomed, many companies adopted names that would capitalise on industry keywords i.e. www.Londonseocompany.com whose branded anchor text may legitimately read something like; “Find out more about London SEO Company”. Boom, there you’ve used your company/brand name, which could also happen when sites naturally link to them.”
We also came across such domain names as smoking-cessation.org, which ranked #1 for “smoking cessation” even after the EMD update, and quickweightloss.net, still ranking for “quick weight loss”. Due to this, in some cases it was hard or impossible to determine if the anchor features exact match text or just a brand name. We classified them as exact match keywords.
See the major takeaways below:
- EMDs use up to 70% of exact-matching anchors without penalty
Several websites, where the brand and the domain names were congruent with the “money keyword”, have up to 70% of such exact-match “money” anchors (thus proving that over 60% of “money keywords” in anchors does not necessarily lead to the rankings drop; probably there’s an allowance for EMDs and brand names).
- Non-EMDs use only 1-3% of exact-match anchors
If targeted “money” keywords are different from the domain and brand names, the number of exact-matching anchors is low and equals 1-3%. It’s worth mentioning that most of the websites successfully implement the diversification strategy, mixing targeted keywords with synonyms. Due to that, the number of partially-matching anchors, anchors with synonyms and long-tail keywords was up to 50% across all websites. Alternatively, when domain and brand names did not match “money” keywords, the percentage of inbound links with the brand name as anchor ranged from 1 to 7%.
- Naked URLs are widely used as anchors
The quantity of naked URLs in anchors ranged from 2 to 15%. Large numbers (15-35%) of URLs as anchors were used by websites with famous and recognizable brands like, for example, namecheap.com (40% of URLs in anchors), hotels.com (about 53%) and smoking-cessation.com (90%).
- Non-descriptive anchors are rare
The quantity of non-descriptive anchors was rather low across all websites ranging from 2 to 5%.
- Anchors in other languages is the minor type
The quantity of keyword in other languages ranged from 0.2% to 0.8% per domain.
Average distribution of anchor texts across websites ranking #1 for competitive keywords
Based on the research results, below are the types of anchor texts to use if you want to be on the safe side:
1. Partially matching and long-tail keywords (you can even use long-long tail keywords, like articles or pages titles, e.g. “Best Current Fixed 10-Year Mortgage Rates + Refinance Rates” or “Quick Weight Loss Program – Healthy, Easy, Fast Weight Loss”; if your targeted keyword is “mortgage calculator”, you can also use: “calculate your mortgage”, “bad credit mortgage loans”, etc.)
2. Anchors with synonyms. If you want to rank for “cheap hotels”, also use “cheap hotel deals”, “cheap hotel prices”, “discount hotels”, “hotel deals”, “lodging”, etc.
3. All variations of naked URLs: www.example.com, example.com, Example.com, EXAMPLE.COM, http://www.example.com.
4. Non-descriptive anchor texts. As they are not widely used at the moment, check the list below to diversify your anchors:
- Website, visit website to learn more
- view publisher site
- click here to visit the website, here
- Watch the video
- Click here to download
- click here for details/for more info
- Click here to view the source of the post
- View source
- Learn more
- Read more
- find out more
- Detailed info here
- more details
- See survey results
- Go to [URL]/ brand website
5. If your website is multi-language, use anchors in other languages (“Página de Internet:”, “Registo de Domínios”).
6. Brand name or brand-keyword hybrids. (“Traffic Travis free keyword tool”, “Namecheap – hosting and domains”, “Domain registrar – NameCheap”, etc.).
7. Image links with optimized alt text. Alt texts in image links are also a ranking factor, but alongside filling alt texts with “money keywords” only, use such alt texts as [banner], “example.com” or leave them empty.
This research provides a snapshot of the anchor types’ distribution across different niches. The use of provided methods will not only help you avoid Google flag, but will also make your SEO strategy more stable in the long run.
Image source: iStockphoto